Toby will often find himself drawing a triangle with one eye and a hat, like Alcor’s object form, but not quite. He avoids coloring them gold, since that’s Alcor’s color. Instead, he will often color them blue or green. (I can’t decide which. What makes more sense?)

This is a good idea, but we generally want to avoid r!Bills doing anything too blatantly related to him such as that. Vaguer stuff like him liking the color yellow (which he does!) is fine.

Ian is the only one who can really get away with a few things, because he’s the first reincarnation that did have specific ties with one of Bill’s plans. He would be more likely to do this sort of thing, though after the events of Reincarnation Blues that may have dropped off.

As a note, this extends to physical aspects like being blonde or dressing sharply, or having anything related to eye problems or fixation on their eyes. Physical traits don’t extend to reincarnations (in instances like Toby, the universe does seem to have a cruel sense of humor). Coincidences, personality traits, and perhaps some vague subconscious things are still ok, if applied subtly.